Is Fear of Extremism an Excuse to Abandon the Quran? And the Manipulators?
Reflections on Quranic contemplation, overcoming fear of extremism, and guarding against ideological manipulation.
Alongside those who say that the Quran carries multiple interpretations, considering their statement an excuse to abandon the Quran, what is the fate of their likes? There is a group, even if their intentions are sincere, claiming that contemplation might drag them into the sphere of extremism and interpreting verses according to their desires, and from this seed the manipulator arises. Is this excuse sufficient for one whose intention is sound? And why was the Quran abandoned under the pretext of the existence of manipulators?
If we look at the speaker's intention, if sound, they have erred in terms of fear, which they consider a final solution to eradicate extremism, but I do not think it is a solution that suffices. Extremism is a phenomenon that cannot be avoided, so to speak, and extremists exist at all levels. Yes, we may say that the Quran is the word of Allah, preserved from all this, but the Quran itself foretold that in the saying of the Almighty: ﴿He it is Who has sent down to thee the Book: In it are verses basic or fundamental (of established meaning); they are the foundation of the Book: others are allegorical. But those in whose hearts is perversity follow the part thereof that is allegorical, seeking discord, and searching for its hidden meanings, but no one knows its hidden meanings except Allah. And those who are firmly grounded in knowledge say: "We believe in the Book; the whole of it is from our Lord": and none will grasp the Message except men of understanding.﴾ [Ali 'Imran: 7].
This verse was revealed regarding those who leave the decisive and take the ambiguous to mislead people and confuse them, as Christians do; though we rarely see them today in the exact same form, as they argue that the Quran declared that Jesus son of Mary, peace be upon him, is the Spirit of God and His Word bestowed upon Mary, while forgetting the Almighty's saying: ﴿He was no more than a servant: We granted Our favour to him﴾ [Az-Zukhruf: 59], and His saying: ﴿The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust, then said to him: "Be": And he was.﴾ [Ali 'Imran: 59].
And there are those who excelled in misleading people using what is ambiguous in it, leaving the decisive. Therefore, if the solution to this extremism is leaving the contemplation of the Quran and acting upon it, then it is undoubtedly a great calamity. This is what frightens: that a Muslim leaves the Quran out of fear of extremism. The key point is that a problem is not solved by another problem, which is undoubtedly the more dangerous.
Extremism was and remains to this day, and today it is even more evil than before; Jews distort words, and Christians take the ambiguous and leave the decisive. As for our era, whoever comes along twists their tongue and begins interpreting Allah's verses according to their desires, going astray and misleading many of Allah's servants. This is mentioned by the Chosen One, peace and blessings be upon him, as he said: «When you see those who follow what is ambiguous in it, those are the ones whom Allah has named, so beware of them» [Narrated by Al-Bukhari and Muslim].
On the other hand, leaving the contemplation of the Quran out of fear of extremism opens the door to manipulators. If the Islamic intellect is disconnected from Revelation, this makes it easy for manipulators to play with the Islamic mind and spread extremist ideas, cloaking them to seek discord. This is obvious in today's world; the Islamic society was in a lamentable state, and manipulators knew how to exploit this intellectual weakness, committing tyranny in the land and tempting Muslims. Muslims could no longer distinguish truth from falsehood, nor recognize extremist ideas due to severe deception and broadcasting of doubts. With the alarming progress of social media and openness to the world, it has become easy to control people's minds and spread extremist ideas through various means that affect and corrupt public intellects.
Whoever claims to abandon Quranic contemplation under the guise of extremism suffers a double loss: either abandoning the Quran, which is equivalent to severing communication with Revelation and thus complete loss; or opening the door to those who corrupt minds. The Muslim who adopts this idea stands between loss and the danger of manipulators. Otherwise, the Quran itself warned against that, as ﴿Verily this Quran doth guide to that which is most right﴾ [Al-Isra: 9], and the Sunnah also had a share in extinguishing the fires of extremism and manipulation, for the Prophet's saying, peace and blessings be upon him: «The Quran was not revealed for parts of it to contradict other parts, but rather parts of it confirm other parts. What you know of it, act upon; and what you are ignorant of, refer to its scholar» (and in a narration: «And what is ambiguous to you, believe in it») [Good Hadith, reported by Ahmad and Abu Ya'la, and its origin was authenticated by Al-Albani in As-Silsilah As-Sahihah].
Thus, making action upon the decisive and faith in the ambiguous a prophetic solution to this dilemma. Stopping this extremism is more worthy than abandoning the Quran, and countering manipulators is more worthy than desertion. If discerning minds abandon Quranic insight, it becomes easy for extremists and manipulators to mislead them.
Contemplation, which is an obligation upon a Muslim, naturally follows conditions, the minimum of which is asking scholars, striving to realize derived ideas, and stopping at error, which is natural for human beings. Persisting in it is a clear cause for extremism and manipulation.
Fear exists, no doubt, and it is natural in our time. But abandonment no longer works, and it is the easiest option. Engaging in contemplation to dispel ignorance and take admonition from the Quran is a harder choice, but it is the one from which the river of guidance bursts forth. How could it not be, when it is ﴿A Book, whereof the verses are explained in detail;- from One Who is Wise and Well-acquainted.﴾ [Hud: 1].
And Allah is the One whose help is sought.
〔 Notes, Lexicon & Definitions 〕
Gazette Footnotes- Multiple facets (Hammal Awjuh): Bearing multiple meanings or interpretations.
- Ambiguous / Allegorical (Mushtabah / Mutashabih): Verses whose exact meaning may be unclear unless referred back to clear foundational verses.
- Deviation (Zaygh): Tilting and leaning away from truth towards falsehood.
- Interpretation (Ta'wil): Explaining the meaning or clarifying its ultimate reality.
- Deception / Cloaking (Talbees): Mixing truth with falsehood to hide reality.
- Committed tyranny (Baghaw fi al-ard): Transgressed, oppressed, and caused corruption.
- Clear / Foundational (Al-Muhkam): Explicitly clear in meaning, leaving no ambiguity.
- Contemplation (Tadabbur): Deep reflection upon the meaning moving from recitation to understanding and action.
۞Textual References & Citations
More Articles in this Topic
The Quran: A Book of Knowledge or a Book of Morals?
Reflections on the active role of the Quran in daily life and modern society.
April 2025Is Contemplating the Quran Reserved for Scholars?
Reframing accessibility, personal responsibility, and daily reflection.
March 2025Multiple Interpretations: An Excuse to Abandon the Quran?
Addressing common misconceptions and navigating textual nuances.
February 2025